Eh, if it's so deep you cant stand up, you shouldn't be able to shoot at all.

The reality is that you really can't snipe in a water deeper than 1m. I know that this is not Project Reality, but anyways. So I think the bobbing is a good idea IF features are made so that server host can turn them on/off. And why is it so that leaderboards "make no one to build anymore"? 1st, this is not minecraft, live with it and secondly, they will build if it helps them, also, no one will take time building if it doesn't help one bit? You also said that "if bobbing is added, people will build bridges". I see a contradiction here. You say that if leaderboards are put in, no one builds. However, if bobbing is added, you think people WILL build so doesn't it even out?
Also, people will help their team if the stats page of one's profile is made so that only win/loss ratio is shown. Simple, no?
So, my suggestion: Make it so that you only get 4 (2?) grenades when you spawn and they cannot be replenished. Less grenade spam, more 'nades for frontline use.

Your song reminded me of this.

my song:
l:ollollollollol
:you are a fake noob
:you are a gay and fail
:all you think is gay
:lolollollollol
:the end

If I'm using a rifle I reload as soon as fuckin possible, even after a couple shots. If I get in a fight and don't win or get to cover after 10 bullets I pretty much deserve to die.

Suggestion...i know people have said this before or not but but we need secondary weapons because the rifle only has ten shots and a lot of people have run out of ammo fighting guys that have smgs or a rifle with more bullets.

I solved accuracy by using bulky ironsights. It's a lot more fun than default ironsights.

Also, here's old, but good list of features worth implementing (some ideas are long implemented though):

http://aceofspadesgeneral.tumblr.com/post/4583274296/general-ideas

Suggestion: please let us ALT+TAB during map downloads.
That'd make it easier for players to find a server which won't kick them with an error message after a long, slow map download...

(Also: I'd rather have hackers with the client-side hit detection that I can votekick than extreme lags everywhere that I can't avoid)

@Galaxy I love you!

Well I've been saying this for a long time, but the new videos of the SMG in action substantiate my claims. An automatic weapon (particularly one that is meant to be used in close quarters, such as an SMG) effectively handles and executes the intended role of a pistol/shotgun. Plus it has a bit of a medium-range capability; something that neither of the aforementioned weapons have. Two birds with one stone.

A handgun and shotgun.It's probaly been suggested before,but I think it would add more dyanamic gameplay.

Nothing gets done without ideas when developing a game. Regardless of how many people disagree with an idea, it's still something that somebody has thought of that may improve the game. How do you know it will be a bad idea if nobody puts it on the table?

As per my most recent post, please read that. It will inform you that these suggestions shouldn't necessarily change the game globally, but may be utilised as a mod for the server host to use as they see fit.

Players camping far out in the water, with a clear battlefield can make any game last much longer and more tedious than usual. This is more prominent on the Pinpoint map which is probably 60% water.

"Who knows, a shit suggestion is better than no suggestion at all."

Nope, otherwise no one (and by "no one" I mean the developer) will read suggestions anymore.

Also: the "lone water snipers" aren't a (major?) problem at all, so why go through the trouble of changing the game mechanics just to "fix" it?

Thanks to all who posted, so let me break it down per poster to make it clearer.

Starting with my favourite, Devas.

Now Devas, I understand that you enjoy picking off enemies in the water, so here is my [improved] suggestion; have randomly generated island of a small size appear more frequently, this will atleast give players a rough idea where the sharp shooters are and may even the game a little bit. Please do bear in the mind the reason I thought of the whole 'bobbing' feature is after playing several lonely hours on the Aloha Pinpoint map, which had not a single block in the middle of the map, so this made it very difficult of the game to progress. Or even have this effect implicated but it worsens the further out you go? Who knows, a shit suggestion is better than no suggestion at all.

The Kirk; I'm not sure if this happens only for me, I would find this extremely abnormal if it did but the scoring system just isn't correct. I can join a game and instantly have several kills/deaths.

jakesweet27; Read below.

Please also note that these suggestions are NOT intended to be global, these are merely features that I think could be a good addition to a hosts "mod" folder if you will.

if the map reset itself evey couple of rounds i would quit the game

lol loaf check the comments for the beta 0.53 vid

Keep suggestions to two lines or less or nobody will bother to read them. If Ben likes them he can figure out the details.
Seriously, nobody wants to read your walls of text.

I just want to throw in a suggestion: Lets make some features only work if the server host or other admins turn it on. That way people can make their unbreakable blocks and lava water while others can can have whatever they want on their server.

hey dude can i suggest something.well w/e im going at it anyway:
"ya great update dude but this game is missing some real important stuff,aight you better listen up cause' i know my shit.this game needs:killstreaks (YA like in COD:BLACKCOPS (best game ever xD)),regenerating health,deathstreaks,vehicles,m­any new weps (like PSG,AK47 and desert eagle),sprint,voice chat,killstreaks,ranks,better graphics,and btw when u kill someone there should be a message to everyone that you killed him.yo got it?"

The only suggestions that really annoy me are 4 and 5.

I guess its my fault that I hate 4. I'm kinda expecting the current weapon to be used as a sniper rifle as more weapons are added, so its crazy to think that it wouldn't have 100% percent accuracy. Also, killing opponents in this game is completely skill. You have to be able to aim well and hit them quickly if you are to succeed. If the gun is inaccurate, then luck becomes involved to hit someone, and I don't see how luck is a good substitute for skill. I hope I explained that clearly.

I think its obvious that you don't like the "fish", but you should learn how to handle them rather then make it impossible for them to play. It also fucks up maps where you have to cross water, like the urban harbor map.

It's like saying that "tunneling is unfair, so all blocks should have gravity so no one can tunnel." It makes more problems than it solves.

Also, could you explain #3? I dont understand it

1-N
2-Y
3-Lolwut?
4-N
5-Maybe?
6-N
7-N
8-??
9-Y

I'm sorry if you percieved me as agressive, but I was annoyed while I typed those messages, yes, because you basically called me a fish.
Your ideas cannot be "constructively" criticised because they're not even worth adding to the game (besides maybe the leaderboard one), especially the "fish" one, and therefore not worth improving.

Also, "bridge-building" goes under "building", and is fun/essential indeed. But why encourage the building of BRIDGES, and not other things? Bridges themselves aren't essential for crossing water.

And as for "forcing your play-style onto others", you're claiming that everyone should be building fortresses and not being a lone spawn-killing sniper, and you went as far as to suggest that people get their accuraccy lowered when they're in the water, just because they're not building "awesome forts" instead.

I got angry because the main reason I go blue is to hide easier in the water, which is a legit playing style as enemies don't always expect it, and you're just looking down on it and calling people like me fishes. Maybe it's you who should have been respectful in first place. There is NOTHING wrong with picking off isolated enemies or camping far away from your base.

As for forced competitiveness: people will have to have good stats to not be looked down upon, and will start getting angry whenever they get killed, etc...
This'll make the ambiance in-game worse. People will become more selfish than usual ("iU STOLE MA INTEL" drama, less cooperation (no one is going to risk their lives to cover a team mate if their ratio is going to become worse), etc...)

(side note: I didn't claim that you're trying to become an admin, what I meant was that you're trying too hard to help)

Hey guys, just like to say thanks to Devas for having the e-balls to actually give criticism regardless of how un-constructive and aggressive it was. I feel it was a bit unfair to claim that I'm trying to become an admin, I'm just trying to help out. I would however, Devas, prefer you to elaborate on the whole "forcing my play-style onto others" thing rather than just make blunt comments about it. I do not agree with the "forced competitiveness" you mention, as if you read further down you will notice I mentioned having dedicated servers, these could perhaps be orientated at different game modes to suit player preferences?

As for Kirk, thanks for the opinion but I don't think you grasp the constructive criticism ethos I was aiming for, maybe I should have actually stated it. I completely disagree that being able to kill somebody so easily regardless of the distance as "a sniping tactic" IMO a sniping tactic is to remain far away, yet hidden. Possibly this suggestion would be better with a wider choice of weapons suited to various play-styles. Sub machine guns, snipers etc etc.

And on a final note Devas; you made it clear you don't agree with me "imposing my play-styles onto others" yet you replied to Drewgon in a fairly aggresive manner and you are adamant that "bridge building is not fun and not an essential part of the game". Well, maybe for some people it is? Bridge building is a play-style, its being creative while providing a function.

Lets try and be a bit more respectful and constructive in any later posts?
And remember guys these are only suggestions, its not the end of the world.

Not really a suggestion, but when you're higher up than other people and shooting down at them, head shots don't work. It takes 3 shots to kill them, even if you hit their head every time.

I'm with Devas on this one. It seems like the OP is trying to mold everyone's playing style into his own personal playing style.

It's not official because ben didn't make them. gg.

Why should bridge building be encouraged? It's not fun, and not an essential part of the game... Besides that, more bridge building = more griefing = more whining.

Anyways, as I said before, players try to enforce their playing style on others. No, I do not need less ammo, I already have too few and run out of it frequently during my trips to the enemy base.

The water bobbing is a good idea in my opinion, it will encourage bridge building by making it harder to use the water. To add on to the bobbing you should move more slowly and it should take twice as long to break blocks.

Also I would like to add a suggestion about maybe making ammo a more important part of game play. This can be done by making people carry less ammo or making ammo usable for more than just firing (like trading it in for more grenades or for using it to reload mounted weapons.) Tell me what you think below.

I stopped reading at #5, which I found outrageous, horrible and stupid.
There is no "right way" of playing, and I do not want you to enforce yours on me. You want this thread to be serious and good, but your own suggestions can't be considered as such.

EDIT: I decided to see if the other suggestions were as stupid, and I read 6, which I found bad. Leaderboards = "forced competitivity" = less building and having fun, more killing and shooting and hurrr = less fun (and also more people who break builders' stuff because "they are useless"). I am against it too.

Other edit: I don't understand #7. And how is the "don't mess with authority" part relevant?

Last edit: the grenade limit won't be needed, since griefers will be easier to get rid of with the new votekicking system. And as for the "donate more plz" suggestion... I have to admit that I laughed. You are trying to earn the administration/Ben's grattitude/sympathy too hard.

These are over-the-top solutions for small problems. Bobbing in water is a horrible idea. It is a legitimate strategy to snipe from the water, and there are times where crossing water is necessary.

Also why do you want inaccuracy? That completely destroys sniping tactics.

This should be moved to the suggestions area, and yes, there will be trolls and stupid suggestions.