In celebration that I made the battlefield 3 alpha invite, I will now make the highest voted battlefield 2 map as a vxl file for AoS gameplay.
Some suggestions
Wake island
Gulf of Oman
Strike at Karkland

Also, EA and Dice are going to hate me for this but if it gets enough votes, I'll make the unreleashed map: operation:metro for battlefield 3 as a vxl file.

^ Nice idea :D

wake island, i didnt played it in bf2, but played it in bf heroes

I haven't played BF2, but if your making one of those maps choose the one with the most cliffs and tactical points.

WAKE ISLAND WAKE ISLAND
Honestly, do it. The defguns would make awesome bunkers, and the airfield spawn would be awesome with sniping and whatever.

If you dont do it, Ill go play BF1942 instead! :P

Wake Island

This won't work unless you increase the landmass.

I tried making a Wake Island map but the landmass was so skinny that the gameplay would be rubbish - plus the fact that the terrain would favour one side (greens, I think) more than the other, due to them spawning on land, over blues, who have very little land to spawn on.

I'd like to see Strike at Karkand made.

what if you rotated the map, so the backwords C of it would become a U? And double the size or w/e to make it work. That way both sides could get a ( of the map.

The action would still be concentrated into a small area, making it another Pinpoint. Not a feasable map with the current 512x512 restriction, in my opinion.

>small area
Im pretty sure EVERY map, except for urban assault was always about a team dominating a certain area. In normandie its the church, in pinpoint its the tip, in island its the center.

Maybe so, but in those examples (barring Pinpoint), there are alternative areas to fight in. Wake Island, with having such a small land:water ratio, would be like Pinpoint with even less land.

Another thing is that the main area of focus in all three of your examples are in the dead-centre of the map. This would shift the action all the way to one flank, which may not work out so well. If people spawn a miles from the action, they'll get sick of walking and therefore dislike the map.

Karkand. It's the most popular map in bf2.

only reason strike at karkand is so popular is because its the easiest map to play Infantry only on. Its terribly done, otherwise.

Wake island was terrible.

Dragon Valley, please.

Stalingrad and the top half of the battle of britain would be awesome too
http://battlefield2.filefront.com/info/BF1942_Maps_2
http://battlefield2.filefront.com/info/BF1942_Maps_19

Nice ideas, the poll will close tomorrow.
Currently in the lead: Wake Island
Second place: Strike at Karkland

Other Suggestions:
Operation:Metro (BF3)
DragonValley
RoadRage
Gulf of Oman

as long as its not a snow map i agree love battle fireld just don't have many people to play it with

I never knew you made maps. I'd happily request one.

I think stalingrad would be the coolest.... :(

.... are you making one or what?

i joined a server yesterday hosting a wake island map and it was so horrible i quit immediately.

strike at karkland map! FAVORITE MAP EVAH

Forget bf2- bf1942 maps are where it's at.

So er... a vote for Wake Island then.

Wake Island OR Op. Metro. If you don't wanna make metro though it's completely fine,I wouldn't wanna get you kicked off the alpha list.

Alpha is long gone now, beta now. I forgot what it looked like >.>